Archive for the ‘case study’ Category

In the US, 19% of companies feel that stand-alone direct mail generates the most business

Friday, February 18th, 2011

From Print In The Mix:

February 1, 2010 — Pitney Bowes surveyed 4,000 B2B marketers — divided equally throughout the US, UK, France, and Germany – to uncover current B2B thinking regarding marketing channel choice and business communications in today’s complex and challenging communication environment.

The survey finds:

  • An average of 50% of B2B companies in the US and 53% across the UK, France and Germany (EU) report it increasingly difficult to reach and influence customers as a result of media fragmentation.
  • Examining stand-alone and multichannel B2B marketing efforts for generating business:
  • Direct mail comes out as the top stand-alone channel.
  • In the US, 19% of companies feel that stand-alone direct mail generates the most business for them.  In the EU, 12% of companies report this.

  • In comparison to stand-alone direct mail, 10% of US companies favor solo e-mail campaigns
  • (8% EU) and 7% rely on stand-alone search engine marketing (6% EU).

  • In contrast, more respondents favor integrated marketing as the best approach: 30% of US firms cited a combination of mail, email and web campaigns as generating the most business for them (27% EU).
  • B2B marketers recognize the enhanced effectiveness of combining traditional and digital channels — 58% of US firms and 53% of EU firms feel that concentrating solely on electronic media would seriously damage their ability to generate leads.

About:  4,000 B2B decision makers surveyed (1,000  in the US, UK, France, Germany).  Respondents balanced by company size, location.  Survey conducted online, 2010.

Source:  WhatTheyThink, Pitney Bowes launches free white paper series, February 1, 2010.

Quantifying PURLs. Finally.

Thursday, March 4th, 2010

Personalized URL’s, PURLS, Cross Media, Linked Printing – no matter what you call them, they have been the promoted as the next wave in direct mail – finally a way to increase response rates, and interact with consumers.

Personally, I am enthralled with the technology, so much so that I was an early adapter and promoter of it. I went with the MindFire solution as it was, at the time, the most cost effective and the most robust turn-key solution I could find. I promoted the heck out of it – did all sort of very successful self promotions (with an average response rate of 16%). But, whenever I got in front of a client – it was nearly impossible to sell. Not due to the technology, but more so the cost of entry (obviously, for a well executed campaign, it will cost significantly more that just a post card). Clients loved the THEORY of it, but before they signed up – they wanted to see case studies. They wanted to see a quantified ROI. And, when a client had success, the last thing they wanted to do was to share that information with a competitor (even if a different vertical. Would you?).

This post from Print in the Mix finally puts some numbers behind the technology – and the numbers are good, with some verticals seeing a response rate (people visiting their PURL) of over 74%.


The Response Rates of Personalized Cross-Media Marketing Campaigns


MindFireInc®

Date: 2009

Author: Dr. Marnie Brow, University of California, Irvine

Type of Promotional Material/Activity Tested:

The response rates of personalized cross-media campaigns, — including print direct mail campaigns featuring personalized URLs (PURLs).

Sample:

A random selection of 670 cross-media campaigns across 27 vertical markets drawn from MindFireInc’s large database of media campaigns (more than 550 companies and 3,200 users worldwide use MindFireInc marketing intelligence software and services to manage thousands of marketing campaigns).

For an unbiased analysis of actual campaign results, the database was sorted according to certain criteria (e.g., sufficient number of recipients in a campaign; no internal MindFireInc campaigns) and includes a 2009 timeframe to capture the most up-to-date information.

Methodology:

Analysis of performance data (website visit rates, response rates) from select customized, personalized cross-media marketing campaigns.

For the 670 campaigns analyzed, the overall average and median response rate results:

Rates Visit Rate Response Rate
Average 5.10% 3.28%
Median 1.71% 0.92%

Visit rate: The percent of total number of recipients who visited the PURL sent to them via the campaign.

Response Rate: Percent of total recipients who responded (submitted their info) upon visiting the PURL sent to them.

Median: The middle number (in a sorted list of numbers). Half the numbers are less, and half the numbers are greater.

Overall results across campaigns/verticals studied (95% confidence interval):

Visits % Response %
Low High Low High
4.4% 5.8% 2.7% 3.9%

Interpretation: Results for 95% of campaigns will fall within these ranges (not that a company’s campaign will achieve these results 95% of the time).

The industries that saw the highest number of people to whom their marketing campaign material was sent visit their personalized URL (PURL):

Top 5 Industries by Response Rate (10 Campaigns or More)
Industry Visit Rates
Manufacturing 11.85%
Insurance 10.70%
Retail 6.74%
Not for profit 74.52%
Other trades and services 4.18%

The industries that saw the highest the number of visitors to a PURL who performed the desired action (e.g., submitted information) on the website:

The average response rate across all industries with 10 or more campaigns was 6.5%.

Note:  The Response Rates of Personalized Cross-Media Marketing Campaigns report discussed here also reviews pertinent content from three recent reports from the DMA, PODi, and the CMO Council on direct marketers’ attitudes about personalization, their business practices, and campaign results.  Readers here are encouraged to download the report to read more as how they relate to the original research conducted by Dr. Brow.

Take-Away: From the Executive Summary:  “In the last few years, customized, personalized marketing campaigns have been posting strong results compared with traditional, static campaign styles. Regardless of industry or business descriptive, well-designed and well-executed personalized marketing campaigns clearly demonstrate their ability to outpace the competition. This report provides a look at some of the data and conclusions that support that claim.”

Complexity rating of original source:  1 (Complex statistical analysis scale:  1= none, 2= moderate, 3 = difficult)

>> MindFireInc’s The Response Rates of Personalized Cross-Media Marketing Campaigns report is freely available for download (registration required) <<

Ten Ways to Mix Direct Mail and Social Networking

Thursday, January 21st, 2010

(Luckily, I have been slammed with new client presentations which require an incredible amount of pre-planning and research. So I have not had the time to write anything personally – although I have received some great questions about paper, ink, the Lacey Act, and how “green” is electronic marketing vs. print. I will be touching on all these when time permits, but in the mean time I will keep re-posting articles that I have found to be relevant to me or my clients.)

Ten Ways to Mix Direct Mail and Social Networking

If you’re like many mid- to large-sized businesses today, you’re probably experimenting with online customer communities. But smart marketers realize that no single channel should be relied on to reach consumers. So we’ve decided to offer a few tips for those of you looking for fresh ways to mix your mail, digital and other media to promote an engaging marketing message.

Remember: In these new forums, community is content. By leveraging contributions from your customers and promoting interactive features on your Web site, you can revitalize direct mail content. Consider, then, these 10 ideas:

  1. Make a direct-mail piece a membership card to your exclusive community – Mail recipients a unique code they can use to gain access to a members-only area with exclusive offers and information.
  2. Surprise them with pertinent mail offerings — Despite what some think, Web-savvy customers do enjoy relevant mail offerings. Drive members from the computer to the mailbox by letting them provide their mailing addresses in exchange for special offers – coupons, product samples, etc. — made exclusively through the mail.
  3. Get members to nominate their friends – Every page on your website should have an option for visitors to share it with a friend. Expand that with the option to key in a mailing address. Members of your community can nominate friends to receive a membership card by mail or kick off a members-only coupon.
  4. Create a contest – Invite members to write a slogan, upload a photo or share a relevant video. Use direct mail to invite prospects to go online, submit their entries and see what others have contributed. Arouse their curiosity and let members provide the content.
  5. Turn contest entries into direct mail – Have members of your online community vote on content, such as photos submitted by other members. Publish winning entries as a calendar and send it out via direct mail.
  6. Create a greeting card promotion – People love to send greeting cards to their friends, so make it part of your ongoing campaign. Give members a palette of creative greetings with images and slogans that relate to your business. Enable them to personalize the greetings and specify a mailing address. You do the mailing.
  7. Stage special online-only events – Drive direct-mail recipients to an interactive webcast or chat session with your CEO or a product-line visionary. Only visitors with the special tracking code on the mailer can participate. That makes the event special and gives you a way to track response.
  8. Rock the vote – Customers like to learn what other customers are thinking. Launch a survey or poll and promote it to your mailing list. Recipients can vote online and register to see results. You can even distribute results as a mailer.
  9. Tease them – Post a “Top Ten Tips” list and promote some of the items via direct mail. Drive recipients online to see the tips they missed. You can do the same with winning entries to a contest or even with advice submitted by your members.
  10. Take to the airwaves – Start a series of audio or video podcast interviews with thought leaders in your field. Burn the first five recorded programs on CDs and mail them as promotions. Invite recipients to visit your website and register to subscribe to future programs

By looking to your growing online community as a source of material, you can unlock treasure troves of new content to feed your direct-mail campaigns.

(originally published by Deliver Magazine and Written by Paul Gillin who is an author, speaker and writer who advises businesses on online marketing. He is the author of The New Influencers: A Marketer’s Guide to Social Media and the newly-published Secrets of Social Media Marketing.)

Case Study :: How Cross Media (PURL’s) Generated a 16% average increase in sales

Wednesday, January 13th, 2010

(As mentioned, from time to time I will post case studies – this one is NOT from my company, so I have left both the name of the client and printer in)

Climb Every Mountain | Deliver Magazine.

October 7, 2009

W.L. Gore scaled new marketing heights by capturing customer data while driving sales and brand awareness

By Natalie Engler

Just before Christmas 2007, Sharon Cook, retail marketing manager at W.L. Gore & Associates in Newark, Del., sat in her home office watching her latest direct mail marketing campaign unfold in near real time.

As she looked on, outdoor adventure enthusiasts who had recently received postcards and e-mails clicked on personalized URLs (PURLs) and completed a survey about purchasing habits and travel plans.

“There was immediate gratification in seeing evidence that the campaign was working,” Cook recalls. “It gave me a clear window into the consumer activity.”

The campaign — titled “Take Me to Everest” — was designed to achieve three goals: to sell more Merrell-brand hiking shoes made with Gore’s waterproof GORE-TEX® fabric, to collect data for future marketing efforts and to build brand awareness.

“The idea originated because we had done direct mail in the past using a database to do a GPS location for someone’s address, and saying ‘Dear X, Come to the store closest to you,’” Cook explains. “Those mailings were successful for redemption and tracking.”

She’d heard that PURLs could make the connection between direct mail and the Web even stronger, and wanted to see if they could help her achieve her marketing goals and generate shoe sales during the busy holiday season.

As it turned out, the results surpassed her expectations. “Take Me to Everest” generated a 16-percent average increase in sales of GORE-TEX® footwear during the two-week campaign timeframe compared to the same period the previous year.

To develop the campaign, Cook enlisted Associates Graphic Services (AGS), a graphic communication company in Wilmington, Del. Because Gore sells its products directly to manufacturers, the company didn’t have direct relationships with end-user consumers. So Gore brought in a retail partner, Eastern Mountain Sports (EMS). EMS had a targeted database of outdoor-shoe consumers a perfect fit for the campaign.

Cook worked with Karen Keenan, director of marketing at AGS, to determine the best approach for the campaign, which ultimately included postcards and an e-blast, each with a PURL. The postcards, e-mail messages and PURLs all had a consistent graphical look and feel. Each piece featured a Merrell hiking shoe and a youthful climber (both male and female) standing before a majestic mountain rising out of the clouds. The campaign featured 30,000 postcards and 30,000 e-mail messages sent to EMS customers.

The visuals were customized based on the recipient’s gender: women received postcards and e-mails showing a female climber (“Catherine”) and a woman’s hiking shoe, while men received materials displaying a male climber (“Anthony”) and a man’s hiking shoe. The text included two different incentives. One was a free gift of an aluminum water bottle or pedometer with the purchase of any shoe containing GORE-TEX.® The second — which was much more effective — was a chance to enter an online sweepstakes to win a free trip for two to Everest Base Camp in Nepal.

The postcards and e-mails also contained PURLs with the recipient’s name followed by TakeMeToEverest.com (e.g., www.JohnASample.TakeMeToEverest.com). When customers clicked on the PURL, or typed it into their browsers, they were greeted with a welcome screen displaying their first names in large outlined letters in the sky over the mountains and the tagline “One small step could take you all the way to Nepal.” Additional text explained how they could enter a random drawing for a trip to Everest Base Camp.

After registering, visitors received a three-question, multiple-choice survey (“Do you own any of the following types of footwear that use GORE-TEX® fabric or technology?”, “Which of the following [activities] did you do in the last 12 months?” and “Thinking about the last trip you took for your own pleasure (not business), how would you best describe it?”). These questions were designed to both measure and build brand awareness and to test whether the category of casual-but-rugged shoes for adventure travel was worth the companies’ continued investment.

For additional personalization, the contest entry screen was pre-populated with the customer’s contact information. If anything had changed or was incorrect, the customers made corrections. “I loved that we could switch images based on gender and customize the site by using the consumers’ names,” Cook says. “That resonated well with customers. It was targeted without being intrusive.”

It can be difficult to reach people during the holiday season, a time of heavy retail marketing traffic, AGS’s Keenan notes. And yet, despite the competition for consumers’ attention, many customers found the chance for a trip to Everest Base Camp well worth the effort required to complete the short survey. In fact, the campaign received an 8.6-percent total response rate (5,160 visitors) with 73 percent (3,766 visitors) completing the survey and updating their profiles — giving EMS the added benefit of a cleaner database.

Keenan says that adding a PURL to the marketing mix makes it easier to measure the success of an individual campaign. With the PURLs, Cook was able to sit back and watch as a backend “dashboard” revealed moment-by-moment how the campaign was faring. Tucked away in her home office, Cook measured the number of people clicking through, reviewed their answers to the survey questions and even collected additional data, such as the number of people who came because they had received an e-mail vs. direct mail, what time people logged in, how long they stayed and what browser they were using, among other things.

Through the answers to the survey questions, Cook also learned of people’s preferred outdoor activities and their favorite types of vacations. She also could determine how many knew whether shoes they had previously purchased contained GORE-TEX® fabric. The results showed that more than half of the customers who responded were familiar with the GORE-TEX® brand and confirmed that travel-appropriate footwear continued to be a promising category. Thanks to these results, Gore’s wholesale brand partners, such as Merrell, are continuing to develop the adventure-travel shoes.

The dashboard also let Cook measure the campaign’s ROI in real time, helping her demonstrate a direct return on every dollar she spent. “The back end of a PURL campaign is a measurement powerhouse,” Keenan says. “You can track whatever you choose, including sales, cost per visit, cost per completed survey, cost per closed opportunity and gross profit.”

What made the “Take Me to Everest” marketing expedition such a success, according to Keenan, was the combination of a targeted database, good creative and a great call to action. The Nepal trip was an enticing incentive. And results of the “Take Me to Everest” contest were the best holiday gift Cook could have hoped for, she says.

The entire promotion cost only around $20,000. And for that investment, Gore was able not only to capture useful metrics directly from consumers, but also present a holiday gift to EMS and Merrell: important retail and wholesale customers. EMS saw increased traffic in its stores and got its database scrubbed. And Merrell saw a lift in sales of hiking shoes.

“The success of the campaign has given us credibility to try new things and present new opportunities to our customers,” Cook says.

And in so doing, Gore has proven that it’s a company that can take its partners to new heights.

Campaign Synopsis

Company Name: W.L. Gore & Assoc.
Marketing technology solution: Personalized URLs
Number of items mailed: 30,000 postcards and 30,000 e-mails
Target audience: Purchasers of outdoor footwear
Total cost: $20,000
Impact of solution: Generated a 16-percent average increase in sales of GORE-TEX® footwear made by Merrell compared to the same period the previous year.

Don’t use PURLs when:
1. You’re doing prospecting or lead generation
2. You don’t have a targeted database of customers
3. You don’t have a good incentive or call to action
4. Your survey has more than five questions
5. Your landing page is hard to navigate
6. Your survey questions are overly aggressive

Case Study :: 4,500,000 pages color of VDP in two weeks.

Monday, December 14th, 2009

us-map(As mentioned in a previous post, from time to time,  I will be posting case-studies made available to me as a solutions provider for CGX. I will be deleting the “client” name, the “vendor” name will of course be left in. These posts are intended to show a unique solution to a complex problem and to show you what is possible when you think outside the box and partner with a best in class solutions provider.)

The Challenge: (Client) sought a solution that would enable them to present academic testing results for all students in grades three through eight across an entire state, in a clear, attractive, personalized manner that would be more meaningful to and engage parents. To do so, they needed more than four million pages, presenting different and unique data on every page, printed multi-color, packaged and delivered to 3,700 locations – all within a two week time frame from receipt of the data to meet a state-mandated delivery date.

The Solution: With unmatched variable data printing capabilities, including the largest installed capacity of Xerox iGen3 presses in the industry, Consolidated Graphics proved to be the most viable option for this huge, time sensitive project. Awarded the project in January, Consolidated Graphics immediately marshaled its resources and began meticulous preparations to ensure flawless execution. To achieve pinpoint coordination among nine Consolidated Graphics facilities in seven states, processes were developed and tested, and digital managers from each location convened for training. As the launch date approached, the necessary paper was purchased, received and staged, and delivery logistics were established and confirmed with a national freight and delivery company.

The Results: The project, unprecedented in its size and complexity, represented the ultimate test of variable data printing across multiple locations, and Consolidated Graphics passed with flying colors. 4,500,000 pages of individualized test data came to life in attractive, color reports with separate versions for educators and families. The reports were printed accurately, packaged correctly and delivered to the right locations – all 3,700 of them – within the two-week time frame, many even ahead of schedule.

———————————————————–

Not many clients or prospects will ever have a need for a project of this scope – what I like best about this case study is that it highlights what I feel is often the most overlooked aspect of any project – advanced planning and staging. By configuring this project to print at multiple plants (the one I work out of was one of the 7) at the same time – we were able to maximize productivity, shop-load, quality and meet our SLA’s. So, next time you have any project – large or small – talk to your vendors – keep them in the loop, let them help you meet your delivery dates and quality requirements.

Questions? Drop me a note.

The Power of Personalization

Friday, December 4th, 2009

PersonalizationThe Power of Personalization: The Impact + Influence of Individualized Content Delivery

(from Print in the Mix)

“The majority of marketers who have implemented strategic personalized marketing techniques have seen decidedly greater success over traditional mass marketing approaches.”

Date: March 2008
Type of Promotional Material/Activity Tested:

Implementation and integration of personalized communications through such media as e-mail, personalized URLs (PURLs), digital advertising, direct mail, dimensional mailers, newsletters, transpromotional documents and more.

Sample Population:
Over 700 senior executives ranging from CEO, CMO, SVP and VPs of Marketing from across technology, Internet, telecommunications, media, professional services, banking/ finance, retail, consumer goods and manufacturing.  45% represent companies with annual revenue of $100 million or more.

Most of the survey participants were senior marketing or sales executives, though 13% were CEO or president and 27% of respondents “other” with titles, including “VP” and “Chief Strategy Officer”.

Methodology:
A twenty-four question online survey.

Metrics:

Top marketing executives insights into the various effects of customized content, collateral and personalized web interaction on marketing effectiveness, customer acquisition, retention, and business outcomes.

Top Line Results:

  • Senior executives indicate that increasing customer retention and loyalty (39.4%), building ROI (37.4%), and improving response and close rates (36.9%) are the three top reasons driving personalization strategies.
  • More than 52% view e-mail campaigns as the primary opportunity to personalize their customer interactions and customized website content is second at 38.8%. The majority (66.1%) currently use personalized emails in their marketing campaigns.
  • Respondents rate personalization activities effectiveness:
Individualized e-mails and letters 55.2%
Targeted database marketing leveraging personal profiles 34.5%
Opt-in, permission-based marketing programs 29.6%
Variable Data Printing 21.0%
Print-on-demand collateral with personalized content 17.6%
Personalized URLs (PURLs) 15.9%
Transpromotional communications 3.8%
  • The top 3 personalization communication activities tested or evaluated but not embraced:
Personalized URLs 22.1%
Individual e-mails and letters 20.9%
Web site page delivery based on search history 20.7%
  • Print–based personalization methods tested or evaluated but not embraced:
Print-on-demand with personalized content 15.1%
Variable Data Printing 12.8%
Transpromotional documents 12.8%
  • In designing personalized communications programs, respondents cite their customers’ purchase history as their main consideration (46.8%) and yet roughly half of executives report having only “fair” to “poor” knowledge of their customers in terms of areas such as demographics, behavioral data, and transactional data.
  • In examining key challenges for integrating personal communications, nearly half indicate inadequate systems and infrastructure, 46% indicate a lack of customer data/insight, and 43% sight cost and complexity.
  • When asked “Has your personal communications investments performed better than traditional mass market delivery?” over 56% of respondents say that personalized communications outperform traditional mass market advertising while 5.6% say personalization has not performed better. A large number, nearly 4 out of 10, state they do not know how their personalization strategies compare to traditional marketing communication techniques.
  • Personalized communication efforts are said to be effective overall by  many respondents.  However, finding an accurate way to measure and track the results remains an obstacle.
  • The top 3 reported metrics marketers report using to measure the success of personalization:  conversion and close rates, e-mail opening and forwarding rates, and web site traffic and page views.
  • Most marketers said they expected to increase their budget allocations for personalization in 2008:
More than 20% 25.3%
15-20% 14.7%
10-15% 15.1%
Less than 10% 23.1%
Not sure 21.8%

Take Away:

“Personalized marketing techniques are still in the early stages of being integrated into most companies’ marketing campaigns and budgets. While the need for quantifiable tools for gauging effectiveness and ROI exists, marketers are also lagging on adoption due to the lack of accurate and reliable customer data sources. However, the majority of marketers who have implemented strategic personalized marketing techniques have seen decidedly greater success over traditional mass marketing approaches.”

Wanna Learn more about VDP, drop me a note.

case study

Monday, July 6th, 2009

Solutions Case Study

From time to time, I will be posting case-studies made available to me as a solutions provider for CGX. I will be deleting the “client” name, in an effort to avoid trying to sound like I am name dropping. The “vendor” name will of course be left in.

The Challenge: The extensive product & service offering of “CLIENT” requires a significant sales force with over 200 sales and service offices in the U.S. alone. With such an immense sales force, “CLIENT” faced a situation in which important sales and marketing literature was not being fulfilled in a manner that was consistent, on time, and without defect. Haydee Manzanero, a six sigma black belt who spearheaded this project, identified 117 process steps and over 50 hand‐offs in the old purchasing program. There was up to a 2 month lead time through 8 authorization steps to get a new marketing piece into the literature database for the sales force to order.

Their findings showed the following as areas for process improvement:

• Streamline their speed to market
• Increase competitive pricing across all “CLIENT” divisions
• Build confidence in the efforts of marketing
• Keep branding & offers consistent
• And ultimately decrease literature expenses

The Solution: Consolidated Graphics (CGX) was chosen as this strategic supplier and was tasked with helping to streamline “CLIENT”’s marketing literature process. By incorporating CGXSolutions’ Storefront application, “CLIENT” was able to merge all activities into one system that previously required three systems. The real time inventory and tracking information feature increased speed to market, decreasing out of stock incidents and obsolescence. This also assists in developing future programs that complement the sales fields’ self generating efforts in both Residential and Commercial segments. Prior to the partnership with Consolidated Graphics, the inventory information was sent out once a month and tracking shipments was difficult if available at all, representing a dramatic improvement over the old program.

The Results: Utilizing CGX Solutions’ technology generated immediate results in speed to market and inventory management resulting in cost savings for “CLIENT”. At the 2007 Operational Excellence review Haydee’s Six Sigma team identified a 64% reduction in expenses and a 48% reduction in process steps. Total cost savings were measured to total $2.8 million for the first year alone.

The integration of the CGX & “CLIENT” teams throughout the implementation process was comprehensive. In fact, the project was in the top 3 finalists for the “Teamwork & Culture” category in “CLIENT”’s Operational Excellence yearly review. As CGX and “CLIENT” continue to grow the relationship increases in complexity and has translated into many collaborative projects outside of literature inventory. CGX has been able to showcase an increasing array of technology advances in regards to commercial print and utilization of the vast printing network. “CLIENT” has increased their speed and variety to market while decreasing costs of these same functions. The relationship has added tremendous value in the form of onsite assistance with process improvement, the convenience and efficiency of online print procurement, and much more.

Think that a solution like this might help your company, or have any specific questions about the solution? Feel free to contact me!

steve@puttingdotsonpaper.com